Heat Pump vs. Solar Hot Water Systems: Which One Is Best for Your Home?

A heat pump water heater vs solar water heater comparison helps homeowners understand the differences between these two energy-efficient systems, from how they work to their costs, performance, and suitability for Australian homes.

Heat pumps take heat from the air using electricity, so water is always hot in most areas. In contrast, solar hot water systems rely on roof-mounted collectors to capture sunlight, offering the lowest running costs in sunny regions but requiring higher upfront investment.

In this article, All Needs Plumbing examines the advantages and disadvantages of each system, compares costs and efficiency, and provides guidance on selecting the most suitable hot water solution for your household.

What’s the Difference Between a Heat Pump and Solar Hot Water?

Heat pump water heaters work like a reverse fridge. Instead of creating heat, they draw in warmth from the surrounding air, compress it, and use it to heat water. They’re electricity-powered but far more efficient than traditional electric heaters.

Solar hot water systems, on the other hand, use roof-mounted solar collectors to capture the sun’s energy. This energy heats the water directly or through a fluid that transfers heat to the tank. Most systems have an electric or gas booster for cloudy days because they require sunshine to function properly.

Key Distinction

1. Heat pumps: Utilise ambient air, are reliable in most conditions, and eliminate the need for roof panels.

2. Solar pumps: Offer the lowest running costs in sunny areas, but they require roof space and a higher upfront investment.

Pros and Cons of Heat Pump Hot Water Systems

Advantages

1. Consistent hot water supply: Works day and night, regardless of sunlight.

2. Lower upfront cost: Generally, it is cheaper to install than solar hot water systems.

3. Flexible installation: No roof panels required, making it ideal for apartments, small yards, or homes with poor roof orientation.

Drawbacks

1. Noise: The fan and compressor produce a sound similar to that of an air conditioner.

2. Electricity use: More efficient than traditional electric systems, but still requires power to run.

3. Reduced efficiency in cold weather: Performance decreases when the ambient temperature is too cool.

Heat pump hot water systems are a wise choice for apartments, shaded homes, and households in mixed climates where solar may not perform as well.

Pros and Cons of Solar Hot Water Systems

Advantages

1. Lowest running costs: Sunlight is free, making day-to-day operation highly affordable.

2. High efficiency in sunny regions: Performs best in areas with strong, consistent sunlight.

3. Environmentally friendly: Reduces reliance on electricity, lowering household emissions.

Drawbacks

1. Higher upfront cost: Panels, installation, and boosters make it more expensive than heat pumps initially.

2. Weather dependent: Efficiency drops on cloudy days or in winter, often requiring a backup booster.

3. Roof space needed: Requires an unshaded roof with good sun exposure for optimal performance.

Residential solar hot water systems are most effective in sunny areas and for individuals seeking to save money over time, as long-term savings offset the higher initial cost.

Cost Comparison: Upfront vs Long-Term Savings

A heat pump water heater or a solar hot water system? Often, cost is the most crucial factor to consider. This is how they stack up in Australia.

Upfront Costs

1. Heat Pump Water Heater: Typically $3,000-$5,000 installed, depending on brand and system size.

2. Solar Hot Water System: Usually $4,000-$8,000 installed, with evacuated tube systems on the higher end. Costs also increase if a gas or electric booster is required.

Running Costs

1. The average annual running costs are around $ 2, significantly lower than those of traditional electric systems, but higher than those of solar systems in sunny regions.

2. Solar: Can reduce hot water energy use by 50-80%, with running costs as low as $50-$150 per year (mainly for the booster).

Maintenance

1. Heat Pump: Requires periodic servicing of the compressor and fan (similar to an air conditioner). Maintenance costs are modest.

2. Solar: May need collector cleaning, pump checks (for split systems), and replacement of sacrificial anodes every few years. Maintenance can be slightly higher than that of heat pumps, but it is infrequent.

Payback Period

1. Heat: Payback is typically 3-6 years, depending on electricity prices and hot water usage.

2. Solar: Payback is longer, usually 6-10 years, but after that, savings are guaranteed thanks to lower operating costs.

Key takeaway: If you’re on a tighter budget or live in a cooler/shaded area, a heat pump may deliver better short-term value. If you’re in a sunny climate and plan to stay in your home long term, solar usually offers the most significant lifetime savings.

Government Rebates and Incentives in Australia

Both heat pumps and solar hot water systems may qualify for Small-scale Technology Certificates (STCs) under the Federal Government’s Renewable Energy Target.

State-based rebates are also available in many regions, helping cut down upfront costs and shorten payback time. Always check local eligibility before purchasing.

Given this info, one of the most significant advantages of choosing a heat pump or solar hot water system is that both qualify for generous government rebates in Australia. These incentives help reduce upfront costs and make energy-efficient systems more affordable for households.

Federal Incentives

1. Small-scale Technology Certificates (STCs): Both heat pumps and solar hot water systems are eligible under the Federal Government’s Renewable Energy Target.

2. The value of STCs depends on the system’s size, efficiency, and your location. On average, this can reduce purchase costs by $800 to $2,000.

State Incentives

1. Victoria: The Solar Homes Program offers rebates of up to $1,000 for solar hot water systems.

2. New South Wales & Queensland: Eligible households can access discounts on energy-efficient systems through government-approved programs and retailer schemes.

3. Other states and territories may have local council or energy provider incentives. Always check what’s available in your area.

Why Incentives Matter

1. Rebates significantly reduce upfront costs, making premium systems (such as solar hot water with boosters) more attainable.

2. They also shorten the payback period. For example, a solar system that takes 8 years to pay off could be reduced to 5-6 years with rebates.

By combining federal and state rebates, many Australian households save up to 30-40% on the initial installation cost of a heat pump or solar hot water system. After all, installation plays a significant role in the overall cost and long-term efficiency of your system. Check out our guide to solar water heater installation to see what’s involved.

Choosing the Right Hot Water System for Your Needs

The “best” hot water system depends on your budget, location, and long-term goals. Both heat pumps and solar hot water systems are efficient, but each is suited to different situations.

When a Heat Pump Makes Sense

1. Cooler climates or homes with limited roof space.

2. Lower upfront cost and faster payback.

3. Reliable year-round performance, regardless of weather.

4. Ideal for apartments, shaded properties, or households seeking short- to medium-term savings.

When Solar is the Better Choice

1. Sunny regions with unshaded, north- or west-facing roof space.

2. Willingness to pay more upfront for lower long-term running costs.

3. Maximum environmental benefits through reduced household emissions.

4. Best for homeowners planning to stay long-term, as the 6- to 10-year payback period makes financial sense.

Heat Pump vs Solar Hot Water Systems: Quick Comparison

Still unsure? A licensed plumber can help assess your home setup and recommend whether a heat pump water system or solar water heater installation will deliver the best value for your household. Moreover, if you’re considering combining solar energy with your existing hot water setup, learn more about solar water heater integration and how it can fit into an energy-efficient home.

FAQs

Which is better, a heat pump or solar hot water?

The choice between a heat pump water heater and a solar water heater depends on your climate, budget, and home setup. 

Living in a cooler climate? A heat pump water system could be the smarter choice for reliable hot water year-round.

Meanwhile, solar hot water systems are often the better option in sunny regions, where they deliver the lowest running costs and highest efficiency over time.

What are the disadvantages of a heat pump water heater?

The main disadvantages of a heat pump water heater are that it can be noisy due to its fan and compressor, and its efficiency decreases in colder climates where there is less ambient heat available. 

It also depends on electricity to operate, which means running costs may be higher in areas with expensive power. However, it still uses far less energy than a traditional electric water heater.

What is one disadvantage of a solar water heater?

A key disadvantage of a solar water heater is its reliance on sunlight, which results in reduced performance on cloudy days or during winter. 

This often requires a backup heating system to ensure reliable hot water, which adds to the overall installation costs and complexity.

Ready to Upgrade Your Hot Water System?

Choosing between a heat pump water heater and a solar hot water system depends on your home, budget, and plans — but you don’t have to make the decision alone.

At All Needs Plumbing, our licensed plumbers can assess your property, provide detailed explanations of the costs and savings, and recommend the most energy-efficient system for your household. Whether you’re after the flexibility of a heat pump water system or the long-term savings of a solar water heater installation, we’ll make sure you get a setup that suits your lifestyle.

Call All Needs Plumbing today or request a free quote online to find the right hot water system for your home.

Available 24/7 For Emergency

1300 110 230 Get a Free Quote